What is the most important metric when comparing tipsters?

ROI is important, but it should be viewed alongside losing runs, odds profile, and risk so short-term spikes do not mislead punters.

How often is the compare page updated?

The comparison data is refreshed regularly from tracked performance feeds and review updates.

Compare Tipsters

Q: How do you rank tipsters?

We compare profitability, strike rate, consistency, volatility, and drawdown to give a more balanced picture of performance.

Find the best profitable UK horse racing tipsters and football tipsters

Most Consistent Betting Tipsters (Reliable Monthly Profit)

Tipsters ranked by percentage of profitable months and stable performance. Proven reliability.

331 tipsters found

Comparison of 331 sports tipsters - Last Month performance data
	Tipster	Sport	Profit (£)	ROI (%)	Avg Odds	Strike Rate (%)	Ratings	Action
♡	The Dark Horse Balanced Performer The low risk rating of The Dark Horse makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with an excellent 4…	Horse Racing	£-718.00	-20.8%	8.30	10.0%	Profit: ★★★★☆ Low Risk: ★★★★★	Join from £8.70
✓ Pros ROI is consistent every month • Great ROI • Consistent profit • Great monthly profits of £693.50 • 9 Profitable Months last year ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About The Dark Horse The low risk rating of The Dark Horse makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with an excellent 4 Star high profit rating.The Dark Horse averages £693.50 monthly profit…
♡	The Least Expected Balanced Performer The Least Expected is in the Top 10 Football Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI) returns…	Football	£881.25	25.9%	3.33	38.0%	Profit: ★★★★★ Low Risk: ★★★★★	£39
✓ Pros ROI is consistent every month • Great ROI • Consistent profit • Great monthly profits of £671.67 • 10 Profitable Months last year ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About The Least Expected The Least Expected is in the Top 10 Football Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI) returns on investment, making them a great addition to any betting…
♡	RH orP High Risk High Reward The low risk rating of RH orP makes them an especially attractive option when combined with a good 3 Star…	Horse Racing	£413.75	6.0%	10.10	6.0%	Profit: ★★★☆☆ Low Risk: ★★★★☆	Join from £39
✓ Pros Short losing runs ✗ Cons Subscription cost not value for money About RH orP The low risk rating of RH orP makes them an especially attractive option when combined with a good 3 Star profit rating.RH orP averages £-229.08 monthly profit over 3 months…
♡	FinPro Steady Earner The low risk rating of FinPro makes them an especially attractive option when combined with an outstanding 5 Star high…	Football	£-210.00	-7.7%	8.07	18.0%	Profit: ★★★★★ Low Risk: ★★★★☆	£34.30
✓ Pros Short losing runs ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About FinPro The low risk rating of FinPro makes them an especially attractive option when combined with an outstanding 5 Star high profit rating.FinPro averages £146.75 monthly profit over 3 months on…
♡	2 Way Choice Steady Earner The low risk rating of 2 Way Choice makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with a good 3…	Football	£71.50	8.9%	2.28	50.0%	Profit: ★★★☆☆ Low Risk: ★★★★★	FREE
✓ Pros ROI is consistent every month • Odds are low risk • Consistent profit ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About 2 Way Choice The low risk rating of 2 Way Choice makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with a good 3 Star profit rating.2 Way Choice averages £24.83 monthly profit over…
♡	eachwaymornigtips Balanced Performer eachwaymornigtips is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI) returns on…	Horse Racing	£2,709.50	39.5%	11.50	11.0%	Profit: ★★★★☆ Low Risk: ★★★★☆	Join from £49
✓ Pros Great ROI • Short losing runs • Great monthly profits of £948.83 • 9 Profitable Months last year ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About eachwaymornigtips eachwaymornigtips is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI) returns on investment, making them a great addition to any betting portfolio.…
♡	ACTIVE Betting Hub Balanced Performer ACTIVE Betting Hub is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI)…	Horse Racing	£3,426.25	30.6%	14.39	7.0%	Profit: ★★★★★ Low Risk: ★★★★★	Join from £8.70
✓ Pros ROI is consistent every month • Great ROI • Consistent profit • Amazing monthly profits of £3550.42 • 10 Profitable Months last year ✗ Cons Large amount of bets per day About ACTIVE Betting Hub ACTIVE Betting Hub is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI) returns on investment, making them a great addition to any…
♡	Clean Sheet Merchant Steady Earner The low risk rating of Clean Sheet Merchant makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with an excellent 4…	Football	£84.25	16.9%	2.57	45.0%	Profit: ★★★★☆ Low Risk: ★★★★★	£29
✓ Pros ROI is consistent every month • Odds are low risk • Great ROI • Consistent profit • 9 Profitable Months last year ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About Clean Sheet Merchant The low risk rating of Clean Sheet Merchant makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with an excellent 4 Star high profit rating.They have constantly proved themselves in the…
♡	Tinco Steady Earner The low risk rating of Tinco makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with a good 3 Star profit…	Football	£322.00	18.9%	1.99	59.0%	Profit: ★★★☆☆ Low Risk: ★★★★★	£29
✓ Pros Monthly profit increasing • ROI is consistent every month • Odds are low risk • Consistent profit ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About Tinco The low risk rating of Tinco makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with a good 3 Star profit rating.They have constantly proved themselves in the last months and…
♡	The BTTS Extreme Steady Earner The low risk rating of The BTTS Extreme makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with an outstanding 5…	Football	£473.00	50.9%	3.85	40.0%	Profit: ★★★★★ Low Risk: ★★★★★	£14.50
✓ Pros Monthly profit increasing • ROI is consistent every month • Great ROI • Consistent profit • Value for money ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About The BTTS Extreme The low risk rating of The BTTS Extreme makes them an amazing attractive option when combined with an outstanding 5 Star high profit rating.They have constantly proved themselves in the…
♡	UNDERDOG Racing Tips Balanced Performer UNDERDOG Racing Tips is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI)…	Horse Racing	£2,857.75	79.4%	16.14	10.0%	Profit: ★★★★☆ Low Risk: ★★★☆☆	Join from £11.70
✓ Pros Great ROI • Amazing monthly profits of £2515.33 • 9 Profitable Months last year ✗ Cons Odds can be difficult to obtain About UNDERDOG Racing Tips UNDERDOG Racing Tips is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI) returns on investment, making them a great addition to any…
♡	PRO EACHWAY MORNING Balanced Performer PRO EACHWAY MORNING is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI)…	Horse Racing	£3,000.75	43.5%	12.43	8.0%	Profit: ★★★★★ Low Risk: ★★★★☆	Join from £49
✓ Pros Great ROI • Short losing runs • Amazing monthly profits of £1554.25 • 10 Profitable Months last year ✗ Cons No Cons to mention About PRO EACHWAY MORNING PRO EACHWAY MORNING is in the Top 10 Horse Racing Tipsters this month, making it one of the highest (ROI) returns on investment, making them a great addition to any…

Why Follow These Tipsters?

Consistency is the hallmark of professional sports betting. These tipsters have maintained a consistency rating of 70% or higher, meaning they've delivered profitable results in at least 7 out of every 10 months tracked.

Why does consistency matter? Because random variance affects all betting. A tipster might get lucky for a few months, but only truly skilled analysts maintain profitability month after month. Consistency filters out luck and highlights genuine edge.

Following consistent tipsters means fewer emotional swings, more predictable income, and confidence that your chosen specialist has real long-term ability rather than temporary good fortune.

Explore More Tipster Rankings

Discover tipsters that match different betting styles and goals:

By Performance

By Sport

By Risk Level

By Bankroll

By Strategy

Frequently Asked Questions

How is "consistency" calculated in your rankings?

Consistency is the percentage of profitable months over the tracked period. Our system calculates:

Consistency = (Profitable Months ÷ Total Months) × 100

For this category, tipsters must maintain 70%+ consistency, meaning at least 7 out of every 10 months show positive returns.

Why 70%? This threshold separates genuinely skilled analysts from those experiencing temporary good luck. Mathematical variance means even weak tipsters can stay profitable for 3-4 months. Maintaining 70%+ over 12+ months requires real edge.

We measure monthly rather than weekly to avoid short-term noise while capturing meaningful performance patterns. Daily or weekly consistency would be too influenced by random variance.

Why is consistency more important than raw profit?

Consistency matters because it determines whether you can actually follow a tipster long-term:

Psychological sustainability – Inconsistent tipsters might deliver huge annual profits but with brutal 6-month losing streaks in between. Most followers quit during these drawdowns, never reaching the profitable periods.

Bankroll survival – Consistent monthly profits allow you to compound your bank steadily. Erratic performance requires excessive bank buffers to survive variance.

Genuine skill vs. luck – A tipster could get lucky for 3 months and rack up huge profits before regressing to the mean. Consistent performance over extended periods proves their edge is real.

Income reliability – If you're using betting profits as supplementary income, consistency provides dependable cash flow.

Do consistent tipsters have smaller drawdowns?

Generally yes, though consistency and drawdown are related but distinct metrics:

Consistency measures monthly profit frequency. A tipster could be 80% consistent but still have occasional significant monthly losses.

Maximum drawdown measures the largest peak-to-trough decline. Consistent tipsters tend to have smaller drawdowns because regular profitable months prevent deep slides.

However, some consistent tipsters might use strategies that deliver small monthly wins (1-3 points) with occasional moderate losses (5-8 points). They remain consistent overall but aren't immune to drawdowns.

For truly smooth performance, look for tipsters who combine high consistency (70%+) with low volatility (4 or below) – they offer the most reliable experience.

Browse Tipster Strategies

Tipster Comparison FAQ

How do you rank tipsters?

We combine profitability, consistency, volatility, and drawdown to create a balanced view of performance.

What is the most important metric?

ROI matters, but risk and losing runs are equally important. A lower-risk tipster with stable returns can outperform high-variance services over time.